What is in this guide
There is no correct age, and anyone who gives you one is expressing a preference rather than a finding.
What there is instead is a set of questions about a specific child and a specific household. A mature eleven year old who walks home alone is a different proposition to a thirteen year old who is driven everywhere and struggles with impulse control.
So the useful question is not when. It is whether this child, now, and what for.
Start with what it is actually for
Answer this first, honestly, because it decides everything else.
Contact and logistics. Getting home from school, after sport, between two households, when plans change. This is the genuine reason most families start, and it can be met by a device that does very little.
Social connection. Group chats, seeing what friends are doing, not being the only one without. Real, and it is a different device and a different set of risks.
Independence. A child travelling alone, and the ability to call for help.
Because everyone else has one. Common, and worth naming rather than pretending it is not part of it.
If the answer is contact and logistics, you may not need a smartphone at all, which is the single most useful realisation in this whole decision.
The six readiness questions
More useful than any age.
1. Do they lose things? A child who routinely loses a jumper, a drink bottle and a hat is not being judged, they are being assessed for a device that costs several hundred dollars.
2. Can they follow a rule when nobody is watching? The whole arrangement depends on this. Test it on something smaller first.
3. Do they tell you when something goes wrong? The most important of the six. A child who hides problems will hide the online ones too, and the thing that keeps children safe online is that they come and tell you. If the honest answer is no, the work is on that relationship before it is on the device.
4. Can they manage their own sleep and homework already? A phone makes an existing difficulty considerably worse. If bedtime is already a battle, as in getting kids to bed without the two-hour battle, adding a device to the bedroom is not the moment.
5. Do they understand that things online are permanent and public? Not in theory. Can they explain it back to you in their own words.
6. Do they actually need it, or do you need it? Both are legitimate answers and it is worth knowing which one is driving the decision.
The options between nothing and a smartphone
Most parents do not know these exist and one of them solves the problem for a couple of years.
A basic phone with calls and texts only. Cheap, hard to lose interest in, and it covers contact and logistics entirely.
A smart watch with calling. Popular for primary-aged children. Contact, location, and it is attached to the child rather than losable.
A smartphone with no SIM, on wi-fi only. Messaging at home, music, camera, and no mobile data.
A shared family device kept in a common area rather than a personal one.
A smartphone with the social applications not installed. A phone for contact and photographs, without the part that drives most of the difficulty.
Staging it this way buys years, and each step is a chance to observe how the child handles the last one.
What to agree before it arrives
Write it down, both of you, and do it before the device is handed over. Rules introduced afterwards are a punishment. Rules agreed beforehand are the terms.
Where it charges overnight, which is not the bedroom. The single highest value rule and the one most families wish they had set from the start.
When it is off or away: meals, homework, the hour before bed.
Who pays for what, including what happens if it is broken or lost.
That you can look at it, and how that works. Different families land differently between full access and agreed check-ins, and either is workable if it is agreed up front.
What to do when something upsetting happens, which is to come to you, with an explicit promise that the phone will not be taken away as a result. A child who believes reporting a problem costs them the phone will not report it. That is the most important sentence in the agreement.
What is not okay to send, post or share.
Review it in three months, with changes if it is working.
Online safety and the law
The eSafety Commissioner is Australia’s online safety regulator and publishes guidance for parents on setting up devices, parental controls, cyberbullying and reporting. It is the authoritative Australian resource and it is free.
Australia has legislated a minimum age for social media accounts, and the arrangements and which platforms are covered have been the subject of significant change. Check the current position on the eSafety Commissioner’s site rather than relying on any summary, including this one, because this area is moving.
Cyberbullying can be reported to eSafety, which has powers to require removal of material. Most parents do not know this exists.
Parental controls are worth setting up on day one, and are easier to loosen later than to introduce later. Parental controls on an Australian family plan covers the practical setup.
The school side
Most Australian schools have rules about phones during the school day, and a number of states have restrictions on phone use in schools. The rules differ, so check your own school’s policy before the phone starts travelling there.
A phone for after school is not the same as a phone at school, and it is worth separating the two in the agreement.
If the trigger is the move to high school, BYOD device rules at Australian schools covers what the school will actually require, which is frequently a laptop rather than a phone, and devices and BYOD: the real cost covers what that costs.
The honest part
You will get some of this wrong and that is survivable. The families who do best are not the ones with the strictest rules or the latest start. They are the ones whose children tell them when something happens.
Everyone else does not have one. Some do. The number a child reports is not a measurement.
It is easier to loosen than to tighten. Start more restricted than feels necessary.
Next: BYOD device rules at Australian schools covers the school requirement, devices and BYOD: the real cost covers the money, and getting kids to bed without the two-hour battle covers the sleep side.
Headphones usually arrive with the first device, and what volume limiting actually means is worth reading before buying a pair for school.
The one-page family week
One printable page that holds the whole week: meals, school, activities and who is doing the pickup. Free, and we send one useful email a week.
One email a week. No spam, unsubscribe in a click.
